Back to Study Index Scenario Explorer

7-Scenario Design Comparison

The MediaVerse Studio Complex was evaluated across seven distinct acoustic design scenarios. Each represents a different approach to sound isolation, reverb control, and HVAC noise management. The final recommendation is a Hybrid approach that cherry-picks the best elements from each.

Scenarios Evaluated

Recommended

34.4m²

Zone Area

Select Scenario

Explore Each Approach

Click a scenario to view its details, trade-offs, and acoustic performance.

Advantages

Drawbacks

Radar Analysis

Multi-Axis Performance Overlay

Select up to 3 scenarios to compare across 6 performance axes.

Compare Scenarios

Check up to 3 scenarios to overlay their performance polygons.

Side-by-Side

Full Scenario Comparison

All 7 scenarios compared across every key metric. Scenario 6 (Hybrid) is highlighted.

Cost Analysis

Cost vs Performance

Each scenario plotted by estimated cost and composite acoustic score. The shaded region highlights the best value zone.

Hybrid Design

Why the Hybrid Approach Wins

Scenario 6 is not a single design philosophy but a carefully assembled combination of the best elements from multiple scenarios, tailored to each room's specific needs.

From Scenario 3: Full Isolation

STC 65 Server Wall Construction

The east wall facing B313's server room uses the maximum isolation build-up: double gypsum with Green Glue, 70mm studs with rockwool, plus the existing 100mm air gap. This blocks 55-65 dBA server noise to inaudible levels.

From Scenario 5: HVAC Priority

5-Run Silencer System

Dedicated duct silencers with graduated attenuation: 40 dB for VO Live Run A (NC-12), 25 dB shared trunk Run B + 15 dB branch Run B1 for Control (NC-18), 10 dB branch Run B2 for Editing (NC-25), and 25 dB Run C for Video Studio (NC-18). Low terminal velocities prevent regenerated noise.

From Scenario 2: VO Optimized

NC-20 VO Live Focus

The VO Live room receives the highest acoustic priority: triple-pane observation window (STC 50), full bass trap coverage, 70% wall absorption, and the tightest RT60 target (0.15-0.25s).

From Scenario 4: Budget Smart

Cost-Effective Editing Suite Walls

The Editing Suite, being the least acoustically critical room (NC-35), uses single-layer gypsum partitions (STC 40) rather than expensive double-layer builds. This saves cost where it matters least.

Decision Matrix

Weighted Scoring Analysis

Five criteria weighted by project priority. Each scenario scored 1-10. Weighted totals confirm the Hybrid approach as the optimal choice.

Recommendation

Scenario 6 (Hybrid) achieves the highest weighted score of 8.25, delivering near-maximum acoustic performance while keeping costs 30-40% below the Full Isolation and Future-Proof scenarios. It is the recommended design for the MediaVerse Studio Complex.